
Published cancellation figures should be read in context. A national rate does not establish how often deals fall through in New York City, and a rate based on signed contracts does not account for negotiations that end before signing.
At Poltielov Law Firm P.C., attorney Rafael Ariel Poltielov represents buyers and sellers in real estate transactions and contract disputes across Queens, Brooklyn, the Bronx, and Nassau County. Call (718) 520-0085 for a free consultation.
An accepted offer is not the same as a binding contract. In a typical New York residential transaction, an accepted offer alone does not obligate either party to complete the sale. The parties generally proceed to a formal written contract, with enforceability depending on the agreement and the circumstances.
A signed contract changes each party’s obligations. The buyer typically submits a contract deposit with the signed contract. Once a binding agreement is in place, both parties must comply with its terms, including any contingencies and cancellation procedures. Either party may still be able to cancel under specific contract provisions, such as a mortgage or board approval contingency, but backing out without a valid reason can lead to a breach of contract claim.
Our article on whether a seller can back out of a real estate contract in NYC explains these rules in more detail.
A delayed closing is not necessarily a failed deal. Many NYC contracts set a closing date “on or about” a certain day, which generally allows a reasonable delay. Closings are often pushed back because of lender timing, board review, or title issues, and the deal still closes. Missing a closing date can have different consequences when the contract makes time of the essence or a party serves a valid time of the essence notice. Such a notice generally must clearly identify the deadline, provide a reasonable time to close, and state that failure to perform will be treated as a default.
Mortgage financing or appraisal problems can prevent a deal from closing. A buyer’s loan may be denied, delayed, or reduced if the property appraises below the purchase price. Many contracts include a mortgage contingency that allows the buyer to cancel within a set period if a loan commitment isn’t obtained, but the specific terms matter.
Inspection findings and disagreements over repairs can also end a deal. In New York City, buyers often inspect a property before signing the contract, and many sales are “as is.” If an inspection reveals serious issues, the buyer may walk away before signing or try to renegotiate the price.
Co-op transactions can involve additional approval requirements and building-related concerns. Many Queens and Manhattan buyers purchase co-op apartments, which require board approval. Co-op boards generally have broad discretion to review purchase applications, but their decisions remain subject to applicable antidiscrimination laws and other legal limits. Concerns about a building’s finances, pending assessments, or litigation can also cause buyers to reconsider.
Title defects, liens, and ownership disputes may surface during the title search. Unpaid liens, judgments, open building violations, or questions about who has the right to sell can delay or derail a closing if they can’t be resolved.
Missed deadlines, unmet conditions, or a change of mind can also cause a deal to fail. Whether that’s allowed depends on the contract and the stage of the deal.
In New York, buyers commonly put down a deposit, often around 10% of the purchase price, which is usually held in escrow by the seller’s attorney. What happens to that money depends on why the deal ended.
If the buyer cancels under a valid contract provision, such as a mortgage contingency or a co-op board rejection, and follows the required notice procedures and deadlines, the deposit is generally returned. These protections depend on the exact contract language, so it’s important to understand them before signing.
If the buyer defaults without a valid legal excuse, the seller may be entitled to retain the contract deposit as liquidated damages, depending on the agreement and the circumstances. If the seller defaults, the buyer may be entitled to the return of the deposit and may have other remedies, depending on the contract and the circumstances.
The escrow agreement controls the procedures for releasing the deposit. If the parties dispute entitlement to the funds, the money may remain in escrow pending an agreement, a court order, or another release procedure authorized by the agreement.
Not every failed deal is a breach. It helps to separate three situations:
When a breach of contract occurs, the other party may have remedies such as keeping or recovering the deposit, seeking damages, or, in some cases, asking a court to require the sale to go forward.
While no deal is guaranteed, buyers and sellers can reduce the risk of problems by:
Our real estate transactions attorneys guide buyers and sellers through each stage of the process.
Poltielov Law Firm P.C. represents buyers and sellers in real estate transactions and contract disputes throughout Queens, Brooklyn, the Bronx, and Nassau County. Attorney Rafael Ariel Poltielov can review your agreement, assess your rights to the deposit, and explain options for completing the sale or resolving a dispute.
Contact Poltielov Law Firm P.C. at (718) 520-0085 for a free consultation.





